SP Show Reviews


"Pumpkins concert in New Orleans"
Feb 5, Review from New Orleans Newspaper

For the first 90 minutes of the Smashing Pumpkins' tour finale at the UNO Lakefront Arena Wednesday, frontman Billy Corgan and company seemed intent on repeating all the mistakes that made their November appearance in Biloxi, Miss., such a mess.

The bass and drums were drowned out in a muddled, highend din. Corgan, his rasp even more ragged than usual, oversang badly. He bleated "despite all my rage/I am still just a rat in cage" as the band raced through the chorus of "Bullet With Butterfly Wings," undermining the song's impact. The rigors of a long tour seemed to have taken a toll; even the segment in which audience members were brought onstage to dance during the bouncy "1979" was dispirited.Alluding to his frequently expressed desire to move the Pumpkins away from hard rock in favor of acoustic music, Corgan quipped, "We hope you enjoy your future in rock 'n' roll we certainly won't have much to do with it." At that point in the evening, I, for one, was not inclined to lament the electrified Pumpkins' possible passing. But then things got interesting.

This being the final night of the epic 180-date "Mellon Collie & the lnfinite Sadness" tour, the Pumpkins chucked arena rock convention in a series of encores as long as the regular set. First they brought out The Frogs, an avant-garde trio that records for a small label partially owned by the: Pumpkins; Corgan joined them for a ditty poking fun at rock-stardom, laughing as he sang; "I only play for money/I don't give a f--- about the fans."

Then the Pumpkins got serious. Against a backdrop of amorphous shapes and colors, illuminated by incessant strobes, Corgan, second guitarist James Iha, bassist D'Arcy and drummer Matt Walker embarked on a journey into hard psychedelia, making only fleeting references to formal songs. Corgan even howled his way through a long fantasia monologue that indicated he still has some issues to resolve, especially when it comes to women.

Similar jams on past Pumpkins tours amounted to pointless ;squalls of feedback. But this was much more, a maelstrom of power and beauty and majesty especially the final, uninterrupted 30-minute marathon. As D'Arcy and Walker laid a foundation, the two guitarists set off into the stratosphere, Iha's warm, fuzzy tone contrasting with Corgan's searing lead. Then met up, playing briefly in tandem before setting off once again.

They finally crashed to a halt at midnight, three hours after the opening song. The house lights came up to reveal many fans had already bailed out - a point not lost on Corgan. "You see all those empty seats?" he said to the remaining diehards. "That's not who we play for - we play for you. I want you to remember, we won't forget who you are, so you don't forget about us."

No one who had experienced the previous jaw-dropping 90 minutes likely will. If the Pumpkins do take the unplugged path in the future, this was a devastatingly effective final statement on the hard rock phase of their career.

Return to the Show Reviews page